Just a quickie during lunch (really more of a placeholder for later).
This may be a bit of a duh, but it occurs to me that it’s worth thinking about the differences between impulses and compulsions.
For example, I consider that I’ve been pretty much on track since Sunday. That makes today day 5. However, I had to really think about whether or not to count yesterday, as I was at Ruby Tuesday’s last night for dinner. I was looking at the Smart Eating section of their menu, and was waffling between ordering something more healthy (like the petite sirloin with just 8 grams of fat) or less (the Church Street Chicken with 31 grams of fat).
Yep, I went with the chicken. And you know what? It was really good :).
Now, I count yesterday as on track, because while it wasn’t as healthy as I could have ordered, it wasn’t horrible. Yep, I had a little bacon and some cheese with my chicken, but I also had broccoli, mushrooms, and brown rice with a tomato garnish. Not exactly a Big Mac and fries!
Ultimately, what I did was give in to an impulse; I meant to order something more healthy, but when confronted with a choice (two supposedly “healthy” option with more or less fat), I chose the less healthier of the two options. Yeah, I know that it isn’t that “bad,” but on the other hand, I’m off for vacation for a week. I could have banked those calories!
What this wasn’t was a compulsion. The impulse was “hey, this looks yummy, let’s eat that.” Which is just like the eating good stuff at a party, stopping into the bakery when you walk by, etc.
This, to me, is considerably different from my more problematic behavior, which involves doing something that you know is pretty much harmful (stuffing yourself with a whole pizza or drinking a whole bottle of wine followed by a whole crapload of Chinese food). That’s compulsive. And for almost a month, I was really having difficulty stopping. Seems to me that both need to be worked on.
BTW, Susan had an interesting comment earlier this week which is on the same kind of topic:
I feel that binges arise from one thing — deprivation. Deprivation and insatiability go hand. When you are depriving yourself of something you really want and you finally get it, you want as much of it as you can get before it’s taken away again.
I think compulsive eating and bingeing are two very different things. I only binge when I’m trying to diet and starve my body. I eat compulsively when I’m not taking care of myself emotionally. You can’t feed a feeling with food, but I think when I get to urge to eat when I’m not physically hungry or continue eating at a meal when I’m already satisfied, it’s because I’m trying not to feel something.
I don’t know that I agree that compulsive eating and bingeing are two different things. But I see her point about different origins for these behaviors.